Blog image for old 401(k) and 401(k) rollover including image of a stack of jeans.

What to do with Your Old 401(k)

How 401(k)s are Like my Old Jeans

One of the most common questions I get seems to be “What should I do with my old 401(k)?”  In my experience of working with clients, old 401(k)s seem to get the treatment of that pair of jeans that I outgrew a decade ago…I know I still have them, they are likely somewhere safe, and if I had to find them I probably could.  While this might be ok for your old jeans, having your money work for you within the context of your goals is significantly more important than reuniting with that pair that you just might fit into again someday.  This is one of the main reasons that rolling over your old 401(k) is typically a good idea.  In this blog, we explore the ins and outs of 401(k) rollovers, what your options are, and how to roll it over once you have made a decision.  

Pile of laundry representing how old jeans are like old 401(k)s.

Understanding the Importance of 401(k) Rollovers

A 401(k) rollover involves transferring funds from a former employer’s retirement plan into an Individual Retirement Account (IRA) or a new employer’s retirement plan. This process offers several potential benefits, including expanded investment options, enhanced flexibility, and streamlined financial management.

When faced with the decision of whether to rollover your 401(k), it’s essential to weigh the pros and cons of each option carefully. Let’s explore the various factors to consider when evaluating your 401(k) rollover options.

Assessing Your 401(k) Options: Pros and Cons

Cash Out

While cashing out your 401(k) may provide immediate access to funds, it’s generally not advisable due to significant tax implications and penalties. Withdrawals from a 401(k) before age 59 ½ are subject to ordinary income tax plus a 10% early withdrawal penalty, thus eroding your retirement savings. That being said, if the amount is very small, say $500 or less, and you are in a low tax bracket anyway, this can sometimes be the simplest option. In any other situation, this is typically not the best option.

Leave Funds in Current 401(k)

Leaving your funds in your former employer’s 401(k) plan may be a viable option if the plan offers low fees, strong investment options, and adequate legal protections. However, this approach may limit your ability to consolidate retirement accounts and access a broader range of investment opportunities.

Roll Funds to a New 401(k)

If you’re transitioning to a new employer that offers a 401(k) plan with favorable features, rolling your funds into the new plan can be a convenient option. Benefits may include consolidated account management, employer matching contributions, and access to investment options tailored to your new retirement goals. This ca be particularly compelling if you have a higher income and would still like to contribute to your Roth IRA without the complications of the pro-rata rule.

Roll Funds into a Rollover IRA

Opting for a rollover IRA provides the greatest flexibility and control over your retirement savings. With an IRA, you gain access to a vast array of investment choices, including stocks, bonds, mutual funds, ETFs, and more. Additionally, IRAs offer tax advantages, estate planning benefits, and the ability to customize your investment strategy to align with your unique financial objectives. Also, this option allows you to choose a financial adviser you trust rather than the one assigned to your account by your past or current employer.

Exploring the Advantages of Rollover IRAs

While each 401(k) rollover option has its merits, rolling funds into an IRA offers several distinct advantages:

Expanded Investment Choices

IRAs offer unparalleled flexibility when it comes to investment selection. Unlike many employer-sponsored 401(k) plans, which may have limited investment options, IRAs allow you to diversify your portfolio across a wide range of asset classes and investment vehicles.

Tax Efficiency

Rollover IRAs offer potential tax benefits, including the opportunity to convert traditional IRA funds into Roth IRAs for tax-free withdrawals in retirement. By strategically managing your IRA withdrawals, you can minimize tax liabilities and maximize your retirement income.

Flexible Withdrawal Options

Unlike 401(k) plans, which may have restrictive withdrawal rules, IRAs offer greater flexibility in accessing your retirement funds, particularly while still in your working years. Whether you need to take periodic distributions, make early withdrawals for qualifying expenses, or leverage Roth IRA conversion strategies, an IRA provides the flexibility to adapt to changing financial needs throughout retirement.

Consolidated Account Management

Consolidating multiple retirement accounts into a single IRA can simplify your financial life and streamline account management. By centralizing your retirement assets, you can track performance, monitor investment allocations, and adjust your strategy as needed to stay on track toward your long-term goals.

Graph paper with red, maze like line drawn along it and crumpled up papers around it.

Making Informed Decisions: Factors to Consider

When contemplating a 401(k) rollover, it’s essential to consider several key factors to ensure that your decision aligns with your financial objectives:

Investment Options

Evaluate the investment choices available within your current 401(k) plan and compare them to the options offered by potential rollover destinations, such as an IRA or a new employer’s plan. Consider factors such as diversification, risk tolerance, and long-term growth potential when selecting investment vehicles for your retirement portfolio.

Fees and Expenses

Assess the fees associated with your current 401(k) plan, including administrative fees, investment management fees, and any other expenses that may impact your returns over time. Compare these costs to the fee structures of alternative retirement accounts, such as IRAs, to determine which option offers the most cost-effective solution for your retirement savings.

Withdrawal Provisions

It’s crucial to grasp the varying withdrawal provisions associated with each rollover option before making any decisions regarding your retirement savings. While 401(k) plans typically permit withdrawals after reaching age 55, certain plans may restrict in-service withdrawals, meaning disbursements while still employed with the company are not allowed. Understanding your intended usage of the funds and the timing of potential withdrawals can provide valuable insight into determining the most suitable rollover option for your individual circumstances.

Tax Considerations

Evaluate the tax implications of each rollover option, including potential tax consequences, required minimum distributions (RMDs), and eligibility for Roth IRA conversions. Consider consulting with a tax advisor or financial planner to develop a tax-efficient retirement distribution strategy that minimizes tax liabilities and maximizes after-tax income in retirement.

Navigating the Rollover Process: Tips for Success

Once you’ve decided to proceed with a 401(k) rollover, it’s essential to follow these steps to ensure a smooth transition and preserve the tax-advantaged status of your retirement assets:

Conduct Due Diligence

Research potential rollover destinations, such as IRA custodians or new employer-sponsored plans, to identify reputable providers with competitive fees, strong investment options, and reliable customer service.

Initiate the Rollover

Contact your former employer’s retirement plan administrator to request a rollover distribution form and initiate the transfer of funds. Ensure that you follow the rollover instructions carefully to avoid potential tax penalties or delays in processing.

Complete Required Documentation

Provide any necessary documentation, such as proof of identification, account statements, or tax forms, to facilitate the rollover process. Be prepared to verify your eligibility for the rollover and comply with any administrative requirements specified by the plan administrator or custodian.

Monitor the Transfer

Keep track of the rollover transaction and confirm receipt of funds by the receiving institution. Follow up with the plan administrator or custodian to resolve any issues or discrepancies that may arise during the transfer process.

Review and Reallocate

Once the rollover is complete, review your new retirement account statement and reallocate your investment holdings as needed to align with your long-term financial goals and risk tolerance. Consider consulting with a financial advisor or investment professional to develop a diversified portfolio strategy tailored to your individual needs and objectives.

Update Beneficiary Designations

Review and update beneficiary designations for your new retirement account to ensure that your assets are distributed according to your wishes in the event of your passing. Consider factors such as changes in marital status, family dynamics, and estate planning goals when updating beneficiary information.

Stay Informed

Stay informed about changes in tax laws, retirement regulations, and investment trends that may impact your retirement savings strategy. Regularly review your retirement accounts and financial plan to assess performance, adjust asset allocations, and make informed decisions to optimize your retirement wealth over time.

Middle aged couple looking at computer screen to represent peace of mind in using financial advisor.

Maximizing Retirement Wealth: A Long-Term Perspective

When it comes to retirement planning, taking a long-term perspective is essential. While the decision to rollover your 401(k) may seem daunting, it’s important to consider the potential benefits in the context of your overall financial objectives and retirement goals. By carefully evaluating your options, understanding the implications of each choice, and seeking guidance from financial professionals when needed, you can make informed decisions that maximize your retirement wealth and secure your financial future.

Of course, to some, all of this can seem a bit overwhelming.  Working with a trusted advisor can help you to navigate the complexities of retirement planning and achieve your financial goals with confidence. Whether you’re considering a 401(k) rollover, developing a comprehensive retirement strategy, or exploring investment opportunities, having a qualified financial advisor can be worth their weight in gold…that means that a 200-pound advisor is worth nearly $5.8 Million Dollars!  Okay, maybe a trusted financial advisor can’t make you a multi-millionaire overnight, but they can give you something even more valuable…peace of mind.

This post is for education and entertainment purposes only. Nothing should be construed as investment, tax, or legal advice.

Scroll to Top